forums
new posts
donate
UER Store
events
location db
db map
search
members
faq
terms of service
privacy policy
register
login




UER Forum > UE Main > Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing? (Viewed 831 times)
whitehawk28 


Location: Illinois
Gender: Male
Total Likes: 10 likes




 |  | 
Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing?
< on 5/2/2021 6:03 AM >
Reply with Quote
Posted on Forum: UER Forum
I know a common mutual rule is to not steal from locations? I always wondered if the that rule applied to metal detecting or not. Given that its underground most of the time, I could see arguments for both sides.




EnvoyToTheMolePeople 


Location: PA, NJ
Gender: Male
Total Likes: 66 likes




 |  | 
Re: Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing?
< Reply # 1 on 5/2/2021 2:24 PM >
Reply with Quote
Posted on Forum: UER Forum
Hey, finally something I'm an expert on. I've probably spent more time metal detecting abandoned locations than actually going inside them. I certainly don't think it counts as stealing, unless the place has a real historical value. For example, here in NJ there is a very old house with significant history (I believe it is the oldest house in the county) that is currently abandoned. I'd avoid that, on the grounds that it has history and could be subject to archaeology in the future. There was also a relatively famous abandoned house right next to the Monmouth battlefield, and I would avoid that for the same reason. However, I have done a few abandoned houses in my hometown in broad daylight, and nobody objected. As a matter of fact, one of my high school teachers saw me at one of them, and it turns out that it was the first house she had ever lived in. Abandoned mining villages are one of my personal favorites because oftentimes nothing was removed when the mines closed and everybody simply went home and never returned. There are many abandoned mines that still have equipment and artifacts strewn around the ground from over 100 years ago.




SaladKing 


Total Likes: 181 likes




 |  | 
Re: Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing?
< Reply # 2 on 5/2/2021 5:53 PM >
Reply with Quote
Posted on Forum: UER Forum
I've gotta disagree, just because it's underground doesn't mean it doesn't belong to the site/property. I (and probably the law as well) believe that if you don't have explicit permission from the property owner to both be there and remove found items from the property, then you're committing theft in addition to the trespassing we all known and love.

That said, I see no problem with metal detecting if you leave what you've unearthed behind, or contact the property owner and ask to remove it. Although they may be a bit bothered that you didn't ask permission to be there first. Remember, this is a forum for exploring, not scrapping, scavenging, or salvaging, as interesting as some finds may be.

And to be very clear, I'm arguing for the recognition that whether what you take was underground or not, it's stealing. Whether a discovered item should be stolen remains up to your own discretion - if you do, I hope you have a very good reason beyond filling up your trophy shelf.




EnvoyToTheMolePeople 


Location: PA, NJ
Gender: Male
Total Likes: 66 likes




 |  | 
Re: Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing?
< Reply # 3 on 5/3/2021 1:31 AM >
Reply with Quote
Posted on Forum: UER Forum
Posted by SaladKing
I've gotta disagree, just because it's underground doesn't mean it doesn't belong to the site/property. I (and probably the law as well) believe that if you don't have explicit permission from the property owner to both be there and remove found items from the property, then you're committing theft in addition to the trespassing we all known and love.

That said, I see no problem with metal detecting if you leave what you've unearthed behind, or contact the property owner and ask to remove it. Although they may be a bit bothered that you didn't ask permission to be there first. Remember, this is a forum for exploring, not scrapping, scavenging, or salvaging, as interesting as some finds may be.

And to be very clear, I'm arguing for the recognition that whether what you take was underground or not, it's stealing. Whether a discovered item should be stolen remains up to your own discretion - if you do, I hope you have a very good reason beyond filling up your trophy shelf.


I get what you're saying. I should probably add that all of the places that I listed were already public property or were actively being demolished+bulldozed. I think there is also significant difference between what is in the ground and what is in a building. Especially considering the best metal detecting finds come out of trash pits that have just happened to sit long enough to become treasure of some sort.




SaladKing 


Total Likes: 181 likes




 |  | 
Re: Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing?
< Reply # 4 on 5/5/2021 3:31 AM >
Reply with Quote
Posted on Forum: UER Forum
Posted by EnvoyToTheMolePeople


I get what you're saying. I should probably add that all of the places that I listed were already public property or were actively being demolished+bulldozed.


That's fine with me then, sites undergoing active demolition are one of the very few exceptions I have in my book. A site's artifacts can't be appreciated in situ if in situ and everything in its gets bulldozed, so appreciating them somewhere else is the next best thing.

I still think underground objects deserve the same urbex treatment as those within a site's buildings though.



[last edit 5/5/2021 3:32 AM by SaladKing - edited 1 times]

UER Forum > UE Main > Does metal detecting old house sites count as stealing? (Viewed 831 times)


Add a poll to this thread



This thread is in a public category, and can't be made private.



All content and images copyright © 2002-2024 UER.CA and respective creators. Graphical Design by Crossfire.
To contact webmaster, or click to email with problems or other questions about this site: UER CONTACT
View Terms of Service | View Privacy Policy | Server colocation provided by Beanfield
This page was generated for you in 78 milliseconds. Since June 23, 2002, a total of 737108882 pages have been generated.