I ran that file recovery program, and while it was able to recover some word doc's the pictures it recovers look like this, or don't display at all.
The mp3's are scrambled. I can still hear parts of the song but it skips around like a scratched CD.
I guess that means that it can't recover large files. This must be the fault of the RAID array, but I have no idea why.
It also turns out that there are file system/block errors ( not sure which) on both drives. I think they are at the same location, but I'm not positive.