|
|
|
UER Store
|
|
sweet UER decals:
|
|
|
MutantMandias Perverse and Often Baffling
Location: Atlanta, GA Gender: Male Total Likes: 268 likes
Are you a reporter? Contact me for a UE interview! Also not averse to the the idea of group/anal.
| | | | Re: What is your religion? < Reply # 56 on 2/24/2006 2:08 AM > | Reply with Quote
| | | Posted by Tat2ed White Trash Being atheist is a form of religion..
| Yeah, I had a twinge of dissatisfaction with the statement that Atheism is not a religion. It could be argued both ways, but most people would say it is not a religion. I went to a very religious school for 13 years, and my New Testament teacher had us define "religion" ourselves as a project. The end result was basically, "A belief system," and that is how I still tend to think of it. The definition that I see on the web works with this, mostly. As long as the Atheism in question is conscientious.
| mutantMandias may cause dizziness, sexual nightmares, and sleep crime. ++++ mutantMandias has to return some videotapes ++++ Do not taunt mutantMandias mutantMandias is something more than human, more than a computer. mutantMandias is a murderously intelligent, sensually self-programmed, non-being |
| Asher Archive Pikachu
Gender: Female Total Likes: 0 likes
| | | | Re: What is your religion? < Reply # 57 on 2/24/2006 5:00 PM > | Reply with Quote
| | | The old Oxford definition of atheism doesn't lend well to it in a religious context. I understand that it is a very lose term that people tend to throw around, and perhaps I should have qualified it as a "atheist, non-believer, scientist". That, I assure you, does not belong to any religious group. I'm not just following "a belief system", which to be sounds rather internal and vague, but rather actively questioning the world in which I live. Perhaps it is just the very definition of "belief" that doesn't agree with me. Maybe you should just call me a radical atheist, it seemed to have worked for Mr. Adams. At any rate, seeing that I most atheist I know are also very well educated in the sciences I would assume that, for them, this is not a matter of a "belief system". And before someone says, "but science is a religion", it's not. There is more than faith to science, there is verifiable evidence required. So I guess that some atheist can be "religious", but that is hardly a befitting generalization to all. Every online dictionary that I referenced, since the claim was made that they all come down to a "belief system", well most definitions that I found clearly stated the belief in a god or some other spiritual being. In stark contrast, atheism was defined as the disbelief in a god or spiritual being. I guess the problem here is that we tend to use descriptive dictionaries--those that define the word as it is used by the majority--and that does level the minorities feeling a little left out. To quote some Richard Dawkins, everyone's favourite atheist, and leave you with some food for thought: "There is a very, very important difference between feeling strongly, even passionately, about something because we have thought about and examined the evidence for it on the one hand, and feeling strongly about something because it has been internally revealed to us, or internally revealed to somebody else in history and subsequently hallowed by tradition. There's all the difference in the world between a belief that one is prepared to defend by quoting evidence and logic and a belief that is supported by nothing more than tradition, authority, or revelation." There is also a really good blurb on positive atheism about this: http://www.positiv...g/mail/eml8760.htm I just find it strange to call someone religious and atheist. Atheism is not a doctrine that you wrap your life around, it is just not believing in the various doctrines which call on supernatural beings. Of course, you don't have to agree.
| |
| MutantMandias Perverse and Often Baffling
Location: Atlanta, GA Gender: Male Total Likes: 268 likes
Are you a reporter? Contact me for a UE interview! Also not averse to the the idea of group/anal.
| | | | Re: What is your religion? < Reply # 58 on 2/24/2006 6:07 PM > | Reply with Quote
| | | Posted by Asher Archive So I guess that some atheist can be "religious", but that is hardly a befitting generalization to all. Every online dictionary that I referenced, since the claim was made that they all come down to a "belief system", well most definitions that I found clearly stated the belief in a god or some other spiritual being. In stark contrast, atheism was defined as the disbelief in a god or spiritual being. | Well, I was focusing on the definitions: A set of beliefs, values, and practices based on the teachings of a spiritual leader. A cause, principle, or activity pursued with zeal or conscientious devotion |
A spiritual leader could be a proponent of atheism, but it's certainly not the typical spiritual leader. True, I tend to think of religion as a belief system, but, conscientious and considered atheism as a practice would be a religion, I think. Of course, more importantly, and after I have wasted both your time and mine with this: Who cares?. I apologize for the distraction.
| mutantMandias may cause dizziness, sexual nightmares, and sleep crime. ++++ mutantMandias has to return some videotapes ++++ Do not taunt mutantMandias mutantMandias is something more than human, more than a computer. mutantMandias is a murderously intelligent, sensually self-programmed, non-being |
| Asher Archive Pikachu
Gender: Female Total Likes: 0 likes
| | | | Re: What is your religion? < Reply # 59 on 2/24/2006 10:40 PM > | Reply with Quote
| | | MutantMandias, I feel that it is definitely a valid concern for people. What I'm unclear about is how exactly a "spiritual leader" being a proponent of atheism, but being a "proponent" hardly makes him an atheist. That's a bit of a circular reasoning, I guess. If a spiritual leader is an atheist, then are all atheist spiritual? Of course not! As far as it being a religion because you're conscientious of it or have take it into consideration, well, that's a little far fetched too. Religion, as defined, tends to talk about a supernatural being, atheist lacks this major aspect. Additionally, I don't follow atheism in my daily life as a Christian would follow Christian principals. I'm an atheist and that has little to do with anything than my disbelief in a God or any other supernatural being. With atheism not "guiding" my life in any way, me not following any set of doctrines, and there being no leader (as a "Christan" would follow the teachings of "Christ" even if they were not part of any major sect). Finally, who cares? Well anyone who is posting in this thread seems to care about their religious or non-religious beliefs. I think it is important to flesh out what exactly you identify yourself as if you're going to engage in discussion on religious topics. But I digress.
[last edit 2/24/2006 10:41 PM by Asher Archive - edited 1 times]
| |
|
|
This thread is in a public category, and can't be made private. |
|
All content and images copyright © 2002-2024 UER.CA and respective creators. Graphical Design by Crossfire.
To contact webmaster, or click to email with problems or other questions about this site:
UER CONTACT
View Terms of Service |
View Privacy Policy |
Server colocation provided by Beanfield
This page was generated for you in 171 milliseconds. Since June 23, 2002, a total of 739673592 pages have been generated.
|
|